- Home
- Equipment in the garage
Your air handler is in the garage. Here is what that means.
It is a perfectly normal place to put one, and it has three consequences that almost nobody is told about. One of them is a comfort problem, one is a running-cost problem, and one is a safety problem.
A return duct in a garage is a straw with one end in the garage
An air handler pulls air in through the return side and pushes it out through the supply side. Everything on the return side, between the grille in the house and the machine itself, is at negative pressure while the system runs. That means any gap in it — a seam that was never sealed, a panel that does not sit flush, a filter slot with a missing cover, a joint that has come apart — does not leak outward. It sucks inward, from whatever is around it.
When the machine is in a conditioned closet, that air comes from the house and the consequence is small. When it is in a garage, it comes from the garage: hot air in summer, humid air all year, and whatever else is in there.
None of this is exotic or hard to find. It is measurable with a manometer and usually visible with a torch, and sealing it is a day of work. What follows is what it looks like from inside the house, and what changes depending on what your garage is actually used for.
What you notice, and what the garage is used for
Nothing is sent anywhere and nothing is recorded. This is what we would ask you on the telephone.
Welding fumes, spray, solvent vapour, brake cleaner, two-stroke exhaust and the exhaust of a running engine are all things you would not deliberately pipe into a bedroom. A leaking return in that garage does exactly that, at a few hundred cubic feet a minute, for as long as the system runs — and in this climate that is most of the day for most of the year.
Three things that are not negotiable. Never run an engine in a closed garage, not even briefly and not with the door partly up — carbon monoxide builds faster than people expect and it is the mechanism that kills in these situations. Fit a working carbon monoxide alarm inside the house, not only in the garage, because the house is where people sleep. And if you weld, spray or use solvents, do it with the air handler switched off and the garage genuinely ventilated, not merely with a door open.
What we can do: pressure-test the return, find the leaks and seal them properly, and verify afterwards with a measurement rather than an assurance. On a working garage we would also look at whether the return can be moved out of the garage altogether, which is sometimes straightforward and sometimes not.
What we will not do: tell you that your garage is safe to spray, weld or run a machine in. Exposure limits, extraction rates and respiratory protection are an industrial hygiene question, not a heating and cooling one, and anybody in our trade who gives you a view on it is guessing with your lungs.
A return leak, and it is measurable rather than debatable
If the house smells of the garage when the system runs and not when it is off, that is the diagnosis. Air is entering the return between the garage and the machine and being distributed to every room.
What we would do, in order: run the system and check the obvious places with a smoke pencil or an incense stick — the filter slot and its cover, the seams of the return plenum, the joint where the return duct meets the cabinet, and the cabinet panels themselves. Then pressure-test properly, because what you can find by hand is usually a fraction of the total.
What fixes it: mastic rather than tape, on every seam, with a proper filter slot cover and the cabinet panels sitting on their gaskets. It is a day, it uses inexpensive materials, and the result is verifiable — ask for a before and after measurement rather than a report that it has been done.
While you wait: the smell is a symptom of air movement you cannot see. If it is exhaust rather than general garage smell, treat that as urgent and read the note above.
The machine is working in an oven, and drawing some of it in
An uninsulated garage in this valley reaches temperatures a long way above outdoors on an August afternoon. An air handler sitting in that is losing capacity through its own cabinet before the air reaches a single room, and any return leak is pulling that air in directly.
What we would measure: the temperature of the air entering the return grille in the house against the temperature of the air entering the machine. A meaningful gap between those two is leakage, and it tells you how much of your cooling is being spent on the garage.
What helps, cheapest first: seal the return and the cabinet; insulate the garage ceiling if there is living space above and the attic hatch if there is one; insulate the garage door, which is usually a thin uninsulated panel facing the sun and the largest single surface in the room; and ventilate the garage so the heat has somewhere to go that is not your ductwork.
What we would not start with: a bigger system. It will sit in the same oven and leak in the same places, and you will have paid for capacity to serve a garage.
The same leak, carrying particles instead of smell
Sawdust, grinding dust, drywall dust and general garage grit arriving indoors when the system runs is the same mechanism as the smell — the return is drawing garage air. The difference is that particles also load your filter and your coil, which costs you airflow and eventually capacity.
What we would do: seal the return, then look at the filter. A restricted filter reduces airflow, which in this climate reduces moisture removal as well as cooling, so the filter question is not only about cleanliness. What your system can carry is measured with the filter in place rather than chosen from a box.
What a filter will not do: fix a leak. A better filter catches what comes through the filter; it does nothing about air entering downstream of it, which is exactly where cabinet and plenum leaks are. That order matters and it is frequently sold the wrong way round.
And if the dust is from work you do: read the note above, because dust is rarely the only thing in the air in a working garage.
Establish where the money is going before anybody sells efficiency
Running costs climbing with nothing else changed usually means the system is doing more work for the same comfort. On a garage installation the four candidates are duct or return leakage, a dirty coil, a restricted filter, and a refrigerant charge that has drifted — and all four are measurable in one visit.
What we would measure: return and supply leakage, static pressure, airflow, charge against the manufacturer’s target, and amp draw against the nameplate. Those five numbers explain most bill increases that are not a rate change.
Check the rate too. Compare the same month a year apart in units of energy rather than in dollars — that tells you whether your house changed or only the price did, and it takes two minutes with two bills.
What we will not do: quote a percentage saving for a replacement. That depends on your ducts, your leakage, your usage and your rate, none of which anybody knows from a driveway.
Whoever told you was right to raise it, and it is worth an hour
A garage installation with a well-sealed return is completely fine and extremely common. The reason it comes up is that a poorly sealed one is invisible from inside the house until something smells, and by then it has been happening for years.
What an hour buys you: a pressure test of the return, a look at the filter slot, the cabinet panels and the plenum seams, and a number you can keep. If it is tight, you have that written down and you need not think about it again for years.
Two things worth doing regardless, whatever the test says: make sure there is a working carbon monoxide alarm inside the house if anything burns fuel or a vehicle is parked in the garage, and make sure the door between the garage and the house closes properly and seals. Neither is our trade and both matter more than most things that are.
And the honest answer about urgency: unless you can smell something, this is a job for a convenient week rather than for tomorrow.
About a smell specifically
Note whether it appears when the system starts and fades when it stops. That one observation is worth more than anything else you can tell a contractor about this problem.
About a hot garage specifically
Ask for the temperature at the return grille in the house and at the air handler inlet, as two numbers. The gap between them is the argument, and it takes five minutes to take.
About dust specifically
Ask for the return to be sealed before any filter upgrade is priced. Doing it the other way round is common and it does not work.
About running costs specifically
Bring two bills for the same month a year apart, in energy units. It separates a house problem from a price problem in a minute.
About checking anyway
Ask for a before figure even if nothing is found. A recorded measurement on a system that is fine is worth having the next time somebody tells you it is not.
With a car parked in it
The important one is exhaust. Even a few seconds of a cold engine running in a closed garage puts a great deal of carbon monoxide into a space that shares air with your return. Reverse in and drive out, do not warm an engine up in there, and fit a working carbon monoxide alarm inside the house. Everything else on this page can wait; that cannot.
With storage only
The mildest case, and still worth a look at what is stored. Fuel cans, paint, pool chemicals, pesticides and solvents all give off vapour in a hot garage, and a leaking return distributes it. Move anything of that kind to a shed or a sealed cabinet, keep boxes clear of the air handler and its return grille, and you have dealt with most of it.
With a working shop
Read the note above before anything else on this page. In short: never run an engine in a closed garage, fit a carbon monoxide alarm inside the house, work with the air handler off and the garage genuinely ventilated, and do not expect anybody in our trade to tell you the space is safe for spraying or welding.
With laundry and a water heater
Two specific things. A dryer vented into the garage rather than outside puts an enormous amount of moisture into a space your return may be drawing from — check where that duct actually ends. And a gas water heater in a garage needs its own combustion air and a clear flue; if the garage is also being depressurised by a leaking return, that is a combination worth having somebody look at properly. A carbon monoxide alarm inside the house applies here too.
Four things worth having, whoever does the work
-
A before and after measurement on the return
Not a statement that it has been sealed. A number, taken the same way twice, so you can see what changed.
-
A carbon monoxide alarm inside the house
Not only in the garage. If a vehicle is parked there or anything burns fuel, this is the single most important item on the page.
-
A door between garage and house that actually seals
Self-closing, latching, and weatherstripped. Not our trade and not expensive, and it matters more than most things that are.
-
Nothing stored against the air handler or its return
Clearance for service, and nothing that gives off vapour anywhere near the grille. Free, and it takes an afternoon.